Gartner magic quadrant for CRM

Gartner, the world's leading research and advisory company, has identified several "leaders" in the market for CRM (Customer Relationship Management) solutions, but what does that really mean for you and your organization? 

For example, Salesforce, one of the leaders, can be a bloated, insanely expensive, premature and devastating choice for some organizations, while it can be a genius, data-unifying, growth-multiplying machine for others. It's crucial to know the difference!

Here we examine not only a few of the best CRM solutions in different categories, but the top 10 most important considerations to consider when choosing a CRM platform.

Salesforce: The Brain of Your Organization

Salesforce is a popular choice for organizations wishing to unify multiple data sources and orchestrate complex business logic, serving as the “brain” of an organization. If you are looking for a simple CRM that just works out of the box, this is not your best choice.

Salesforce logoThe functionality of Salesforce is expansive, well beyond its CRM capabilities, and ever-growing. It can serve as a platform for customer service, digital marketing, eCommerce, an integration point for 3rd party apps (and MDM, ERP, analytics, and identity systems), blockchain apps and networks, AI, business intelligence (BI) and analytics, a website CMS and front-end, as well as industry-specific solutions for health care, manufacturing, government, and other industries.

Salesforce is huge, extremely powerful, and complex, making it a great candidate for larger businesses (~$100M+ in annual revenues) or those with specific complex needs and ERP systems. 

This same power and flexibility also make Salesforce a nightmare for companies who just don’t need what it has to offer. We’ve seen instances where Salesforce implementations go multiple times over their initial implementation estimates, sucking money and cash flow from the company, in situations where the company didn’t truly need Salesforce in the first place, only to have low adoption by the sales team post-implementation, which is truly an awful scenario. 

Not to scare anyone, because we’ve also seen great, successful, highly-adopted Salesforce implementations, but you truly have to consult with an experienced industry professional like our company before making such a deep investment in CRM infrastructure. Otherwise, you are relying on the sales team at Salesforce, and their incentive is to sell you Salesforce – not to ensure your success no matter what the platform.

Hubspot: A Popular Choice That Just Works

Hubspot offers some pretty great CRM functionality for free to get you started. Be forewarned that it gets “upgradey” quite quickly. Limits are in place for things like number of contacts and critical feature sets for scaling your sales and marketing efforts. 

This is to be expected from a tool that is extremely powerful, however. You just have to be of the mindset that yes, you can test out much of Hubspot for free or a lower price point, but this tool is a sales and marketing machine that will eventually justify its cost, provided you do things the right way and have a proper business model. That last caveat is something a professional such as our company, O8, can help you evaluate. 

Screenshot 2020-01-29 15.17.35 0

When it comes to user experience, Hubspot wins, hands-down. As an extremely powerful tool, it manages its own complexity with flying colors, and backs that up with a super-responsive, fantastic support team to boot. Don’t need the “pro” or “enterprise” features? Great – you won’t see them until you pay for them, but there are user interface “hints” to show you the way forward as you grow.

Another fantastic resource is the Hubspot Academy. If you are a digital marketing or CRM veteran, some of the material is tedious and verbose, but some of it is actually quite helpful.

Adobe: Marketo, err, Microsoft

Adobe is listed as a leader in the magic quadrant, but who knew they offered a CRM? Marketo isn’t a CRM but rather a marketing automation platform that integrates with CRMs. Just try googling “Adobe CRM” or “Marketo CRM” and see the confusion and lack of information for yourself. 

So why did Gartner choose Adobe as a leader in CRM? Likely because of this partnership between Adobe and Microsoft Dynamics. Essentially this is only a CRM contender if you are running Adobe Experience Manager sites. Another thought is because Marketo integrates well with other CRMs, but that’s a really silly reason to list Marketo itself as a CRM contender. We are definitely not the only one to rant about the inclusion of Adobe as a leader in CRM.

Mautic: An Interesting Choice for Open Source

Do you live and breathe open source, or want to protect against vendor lock-in effects like rising prices? Mautic may be an interesting choice for you, especially if your website is running on Drupal, or you wish to do a Drupal CRM integration, as it was acquired by Acquia

It may not be the best choice right out of the box unless you have a bit of that DIY and technical culture built into your organization. The user experience won’t be quite as slick as Hubspot, and we’re not 100% sure just yet what the acquisition by Acquia means for Mautic, but it may be worth a look for certain organizations nonetheless

Sensitive To Price But Want Hubspot or Pardot Features?

Try SharpSpring. While the user experience (UX) and speed of innovation may be slightly behind Hubspot, this is a very full-featured platform that will get you the infrastructure needed to do some great sales and marketing. 

As a company, we never underestimate the importance of UX, and tend to favor it above all else, because it matters with things like tool adoption, job satisfaction, end-user productivity, and overall success of an implementation, but we also understand there are situations when cost has to be more of a factor. 

If you had the choice between Pardot and another tool like this, we would definitely recommend SharpSpring. Pardot’s UX is more complex and worse than SharpSpring’s, in our not-so-humble opinion. However, Pardot’s feature set can be more extensive in some contexts.

CRM For Small Business, SMBs, Less-Complex Needs

You may have noticed many of these “CRM” solutions go well beyond simply managing customer relationships – they are actually CRMs with marketing and automation features layered on top. Some businesses just don’t need all that, or they have a separate solution already-in-place that handles the marketing and marketing automation.

Want something simple, powerful, and lower-cost, that just handles the sales, email, reporting, lead management, and deal pipeline aspects of a CRM? Try Nutshell or Pipedrive. In fact, Nutshell has put together a nice resource comparing itself to other solutions, some in the same category, like Pipedrive, but also some in more complex and full-featured categories like Hubspot and Salesforce. 

We like Nutshell because it knows what it is and who it’s for, doesn’t try to be more than that, and does it well, and, honestly, because it was our very first CRM many moons ago. Pipedrive, from personal experience, is also a highly-recommended tool for businesses in this category, actually recommended more often than Nutshell.

CRM Designed For Small Business Relationships: Nimble CRM

Are you a small business focused on relationships? Do you also run Office 365 or G Suite for your email and communications? Try Nimble CRM. Nimble is uniquely positioned for small business relationship-building with customers and prospects. 

As far as features go, look forward to bright, colorful dashboards, smart integration with social media, and deep integrations with over 3rd-party 160 apps in order to combine your contact data.

Nimble CRM

It is also a highly contextual CRM, providing pop-up enriched data, whether you are browsing a LinkedIn profile, email, or calendar invite in G Suite. 

Nimble CRM - LinkedIn functionality

While we only have limited experience with this CRM as an organization, we have demoed it, liked what we saw, and think it deserves a special category all of its own.

 

CRM Designed For Sales: Close.io

Sometimes you don’t want to “pollute” your defacto CRM with sales prospects, i.e. contacts that are cold leads who you have never contacted before and who have never contacted you, or who you are in the process of “warming up” through outbound sales efforts. They don’t have any business being in your defacto CRM if your job as a sales team is to nurture them, qualify them, etc. They may never talk to you and come in through a marketing funnel instead, but in your organization that may not count as a commission-qualifying path for the prospect to take. 

Close.io user interface

If this scenario sounds like yours, you may want to consider Close.io. Close.io can help you manage and automate standard sales activities like outbound email cadences, but also things like text message outreach, calling, predictive dialers, pipelines, and sales reporting. 

If you are looking for a CRM to unify sales and marketing, this is not what you’re looking for. But if you are a part of a sales team (or you are the sole salesperson at the company) this could be an interesting tool for you to use that can boost your productivity while being built especially for sales, unlike many CRM solutions which are built for both sales and marketing.

Salesforce Integrations: Hubspot, Marketo, Others

If Salesforce is operating as the “brain” of your organization, it doesn’t actually have to be your defacto CRM, nor does its sister product Pardot have to be your marketing automation platform. There are actually excellent integrations between Hubspot, Marketo, and others. 

This is an important point to consider – we don’t generally recommend Pardot, but rather often have to “deal with it” because clients have chosen Pardot because they are were not aware of other options that integrate with Salesforce.

CRM Integration With Your CMS Website

Integrating your CMS website with your CRM can range from a fairly simple to a complex effort. For example, both Drupal and WordPress have plugins for Hubspot, Salesforce, and other popular CRM platforms. Also, the platforms themselves may have snippets that you can easily embed into the website.

However, it is important to note that if ADA compliance is a concern, ensuring your website is accessible for people with disabilities and thus compliant with industry legal requirements, many of these plugins and embeddable forms are almost always not ADA compliant.

We discuss the topic of CRM integration with your CRM website more in-depth here

 

In Conclusion

Do not take CRM choice lightly. Unless you are a tech company with plenty of experience researching and implementing various CRM solutions, this choice can wreak real havoc in your organization if you choose unwisely or execute poorly. We see many clients that hold their CRM decision very tightly to their chest, yet we are the ones who have seen all the successes and horror stories across multiple industries. 

Whatever you do, please, seek out a trusted technical partner to at least help you decide, and ideally to help you implement or at least to help oversee the implementation by a 3rd party. 

Join the conversation